Can Wireless Standards Work Together?
April 1, 2006 By: Dr. Peter Fuhr, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Hesh Kagan, Invensys Process Systems SensorsThe industrial world has spawned numerous standards bodies. Can they bridge the chasms between IT, RF, and wireless industrial bus protocols with standards that deliver coexistence and interoperability?
The introduction of wireless data transport into the industrial sector represents a convergence of the monitoring and control world, wireless sensor technology, and the IT community. Each element of this triad has its own standards and practices. The challenge for those currently using wireless technology, as well as those contemplating future deployments, is to unravel the tangled web of the technologies, standards, and operating principles.
IEEE Standards
In the wireless world, the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE) plays a crucial technical role in developing standards upon which wireless solutions can be based. The IEEE has delineated coverage zones for wireless personal area networks (WPANs), wireless local area networks (WLANs), wireless metropolitan area networks (WMANs), and wireless wide area networks (WWANs). Variants arise in each sector when increasing mobility and data-rate demands are factored into the application base. Technologies developed for a particular size network can cross into another. Topological differences, typically in terms of network design and deployment, lead to even more variations. In addition, existing wireless services, such as pagers and cellular telephony, must be accounted for, leading to significant concerns regarding the coexistence and interoperability of deployed systems.
![]() Figure 1. An overview of the IEEE 802.xx wireless standards shows a wide range of functionality and capability |
The most prominent IEEE standards for wireless data communications fall within the 802.xxx IEEE numbering system. The IEEE 802.11 wireless standards specify an over-the-air interface between a client and a base station or access point, as well as among wireless clients. These standards are comparable to the IEEE 802.3 standard for wired Ethernet LANs. The IEEE 802.11 specifications address both the physical (PHY) and media access control (MAC) layers and are tailored to resolve compatibility issues among manufacturers of wireless LAN equipment.
The IEEE 802.15 Working Group provides standards for low-complexity and low-power wireless connectivity. Today, there are four IEEE 802.15 standards projects in development:
- 1. IEEE Std 802.15.1-2002—1 Mbps WPAN/Bluetooth v1.x derivative work
- 2. P802.15.2—Recommended Practice for Coexistence in Unlicensed Bands
- 3. P802.15.3—20+ Mbps High Rate WPAN for Multimedia and Digital Imaging
- 4. P802.15.3a—110+ Mbps Higher Rate Alternative PHY for 802.15.3
- 5. P802.15.4—200 Kbps maximum for interactive toys, sensors, and automation needs
The IEEE 802.16 specifications support the development of fixed, broadband wireless access systems to enable rapid worldwide deployment of innovative, cost-effective, and interoperable multivendor broadband wireless access products.
In an attempt to achieve functionality across different types of networks, IEEE committees have been working for years to identify key logical elements in the delivery of data. Some of these elements reside in the description and specification of the physical channel; others reside in the control of that channel (e.g., the medium access control layer). In addition, it's frequently necessary to bridge between the two delivery methods, such as when you plug your CAT5 wire into your 802.11 router. The 802 specifications are meant to define how such interoperability can effectively perform. An overview of the 802.xx standards is shown in Figure 1.
Promoters and Supports
Trade groups have been formed to support each of these standards, or at least pieces of the standards. For example, the Wireless Fidelity (WiFi) Alliance is the trade organization affiliated with the IEEE 802.11 standard. The WiFi Alliance—a global, nonprofit industry trade association with more than 200 member companies—is devoted to promoting the growth of WLANs. The alliance's certification programs ensure the interoperability of WLAN products from different manufacturers, with the objective of enhancing the wireless user experience. Since March 2000, more than 2000 products have been WiFi certified, encouraging the use of WiFi across consumer and enterprise markets.
1 2 3
| sensorsonline: David Gaber: David Gaber is Product Marketing Manager, Inertial Sensing Products, at Epson Electronics America... http://t.co/QK5PY41i | |
| sensorsonline: David Gaber: David Gaber is Product Marketing Manager, Inertial Sensing Products, at Epson Electronics America... http://t.co/QK5PY41i | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: EtherNet/IP Absolute Encoders from TR Electronic: TR Electronic, Troy, MI, offers the CEx58 Series of absolute e... http://t.co/acdzvH4K | |
| sensorsonline: EtherNet/IP Absolute Encoders from TR Electronic: TR Electronic, Troy, MI, offers the CEx58 Series of absolute e... http://t.co/acdzvH4K | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Capacitive Accelerometers from Silicon Designs: The Model 2266 from Silicon Designs Inc., Kirkland, WA, is a hig... http://t.co/hpsQ2L2K | |
| sensorsonline: Capacitive Accelerometers from Silicon Designs: The Model 2266 from Silicon Designs Inc., Kirkland, WA, is a hig... http://t.co/hpsQ2L2K | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Signal Conditioning Board from Fredericks: The Fredericks Co., Huntingdon Valley, PA, offers the RS-485 Mini-Sig... http://t.co/OgK0CY5a | |
| sensorsonline: Signal Conditioning Board from Fredericks: The Fredericks Co., Huntingdon Valley, PA, offers the RS-485 Mini-Sig... http://t.co/OgK0CY5a | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Sensors Expo Exhibitor Inquiry: Sensors Expo Exhibitor Inquiry read more http://t.co/YQ9z3CeH | |
| sensorsonline: Sensors Expo Exhibitor Inquiry: Sensors Expo Exhibitor Inquiry read more http://t.co/YQ9z3CeH | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Sensors Expo & Conference Attendee Inquiry: Sensors Expo & Conference Attendee Inquiry read more http://t.co/nqum9XX9 | |
| sensorsonline: Sensors Expo & Conference Attendee Inquiry: Sensors Expo & Conference Attendee Inquiry read more http://t.co/nqum9XX9 | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Creativity and Problem Solving: Engineers are creative; I don't think it's possible to be a problem solver witho... http://t.co/GiO0fIYR | |
| sensorsonline: Creativity and Problem Solving: Engineers are creative; I don't think it's possible to be a problem solver witho... http://t.co/GiO0fIYR | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: M2M WiFi Access Point from B&B Electronics: The embeddable APMG-Q551 and external APXG-Q5420 from B&B Electronic... http://t.co/bSk7WnYM | |
| sensorsonline: M2M WiFi Access Point from B&B Electronics: The embeddable APMG-Q551 and external APXG-Q5420 from B&B Electronic... http://t.co/bSk7WnYM | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: WiFi-Enabled Lighting Control from Acuity Brands: The nWifi system from Sensor Switch has been added to the nLig... http://t.co/VI3uVlCg | |
| sensorsonline: WiFi-Enabled Lighting Control from Acuity Brands: The nWifi system from Sensor Switch has been added to the nLig... http://t.co/VI3uVlCg | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: MEMS Industry Group Explores Product Realization at Sensors Expo & Conference 2012: MEMS Industry Group Explores... http://t.co/aQt7Hz88 | |
| sensorsonline: MEMS Industry Group Explores Product Realization at Sensors Expo & Conference 2012: MEMS Industry Group Explores... http://t.co/aQt7Hz88 | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Keynote: A Human-Computer-City Interface: Cities are facing unparalleled opportunities now that distributed digi... http://t.co/ZreUVMEq | |
| sensorsonline: Keynote: A Human-Computer-City Interface: Cities are facing unparalleled opportunities now that distributed digi... http://t.co/ZreUVMEq | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Joshua Dennis: http://t.co/74eYv1kW | |
| sensorsonline: Joshua Dennis: http://t.co/74eYv1kW | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: IEEE 802.15.4 IC Market Expected to Expand: According to ABI Research, 850 million IEEE 802.15.4 chipsets, which... http://t.co/EC1mttMz | |
| sensorsonline: IEEE 802.15.4 IC Market Expected to Expand: According to ABI Research, 850 million IEEE 802.15.4 chipsets, which... http://t.co/EC1mttMz | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: RT @SensorsExpo: sessions added to the @sensorsonline live theater at #sensors12 included with all passes. register in advance for FREE! ... | |
| sensorsonline: RT @SensorsExpo: sessions added to the @sensorsonline live theater at #sensors12 included with all passes. register in advance for FREE! ... | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: check out #sensorsweekly featuring @OrthoSensor_ @THINERGY @ATT @Freescale @MiFi @Plantronics @Cymbet http://t.co/6lHQ8eJd | |
| sensorsonline: check out #sensorsweekly featuring @OrthoSensor_ @THINERGY @ATT @Freescale @MiFi @Plantronics @Cymbet http://t.co/6lHQ8eJd | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: #sensorsmag whats new is out featuring @Endress_Hauser in "the proper use of guided-wave radar in steam loops" http://t.co/ccOdeo4Y | |
| sensorsonline: #sensorsmag whats new is out featuring @Endress_Hauser in "the proper use of guided-wave radar in steam loops" http://t.co/ccOdeo4Y | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: The Future of Context-Interactive Devices: Context awareness has become a hot topic in mobile devices. The idea ... http://t.co/9olhd6td | |
| sensorsonline: The Future of Context-Interactive Devices: Context awareness has become a hot topic in mobile devices. The idea ... http://t.co/9olhd6td | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Expo Floor Pavilions: Expo Floor Pavilions read more http://t.co/pGCLGaSc | |
| sensorsonline: Expo Floor Pavilions: Expo Floor Pavilions read more http://t.co/pGCLGaSc | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Concurrent Events: Concurrent Events to be held at Sensors Expo & Conference read more http://t.co/MmGjwE4N | |
| sensorsonline: Concurrent Events: Concurrent Events to be held at Sensors Expo & Conference read more http://t.co/MmGjwE4N | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Connecting Sensors to the Cloud Made Easy!: read more http://t.co/XXKxznjZ | |
| sensorsonline: Connecting Sensors to the Cloud Made Easy!: read more http://t.co/XXKxznjZ | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: 01-May-2012: 01-May-2012 read more http://t.co/JSqONRv7 | |
| sensorsonline: 01-May-2012: 01-May-2012 read more http://t.co/JSqONRv7 | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: HTA to Advance Organic Electronics Production: The European alliance aims to revolutionize the way printed elect... http://t.co/CsPbGVoz | |
| sensorsonline: HTA to Advance Organic Electronics Production: The European alliance aims to revolutionize the way printed elect... http://t.co/CsPbGVoz | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: OrthoSensor Secures Series B Financing: The company has closed on an additional $15 million in financing, bringi... http://t.co/24KSehgO | |
| sensorsonline: OrthoSensor Secures Series B Financing: The company has closed on an additional $15 million in financing, bringi... http://t.co/24KSehgO | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: RT @Sensorsportal: Smart Sensors Systems Design - one day tutorial at Sensors Expo & Conference: 5 June 2012: 9:00-17:00.: http://t. ... | |
| sensorsonline: RT @Sensorsportal: Smart Sensors Systems Design - one day tutorial at Sensors Expo & Conference: 5 June 2012: 9:00-17:00.: http://t. ... | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: #productpicks is out w/ @ABBMeasurement @analog_ic_news @LinearTech @Cognex_Corp @GoodrichCorp @picotech @monnitsensors http://t.co/Fn1LOtK9 | |
| sensorsonline: #productpicks is out w/ @ABBMeasurement @analog_ic_news @LinearTech @Cognex_Corp @GoodrichCorp @picotech @monnitsensors http://t.co/Fn1LOtK9 | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Cloudera: Cloudera read more http://t.co/6Welk86y | |
| sensorsonline: Cloudera: Cloudera read more http://t.co/6Welk86y | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Developing an Ultra Low Power CO2 Sensor: Enhanced building automation in relation to air quality control & moni... http://t.co/piIzBqon | |
| sensorsonline: Developing an Ultra Low Power CO2 Sensor: Enhanced building automation in relation to air quality control & moni... http://t.co/piIzBqon | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: May R&D Round Up: This month we have a mini sensor that measures the magnetic activity that happens inside your ... http://t.co/JzQPNONF | |
| sensorsonline: May R&D Round Up: This month we have a mini sensor that measures the magnetic activity that happens inside your ... http://t.co/JzQPNONF | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Sensors Alumni Club 2: Sensors Alumni Club 2 read more http://t.co/dzUwk2HK | |
| sensorsonline: Sensors Alumni Club 2: Sensors Alumni Club 2 read more http://t.co/dzUwk2HK | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: CEA-Leti Promotes LETI-3S Concept: The latest addition to CEA-Leti’s extensive range of collaboration offers on ... http://t.co/6CYvqb6u | |
| sensorsonline: CEA-Leti Promotes LETI-3S Concept: The latest addition to CEA-Leti’s extensive range of collaboration offers on ... http://t.co/6CYvqb6u | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Ethernet Adapter from WAGO: The 756 Series M12 Socket Ethernet Adapter from WAGO Corp., Germantown, WI, is a tra... http://t.co/uoD6Qy3t | |
| sensorsonline: Ethernet Adapter from WAGO: The 756 Series M12 Socket Ethernet Adapter from WAGO Corp., Germantown, WI, is a tra... http://t.co/uoD6Qy3t | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Host Test Suite from HART Communication Foundation: The new enhanced HART DDL/EDDL Host Test Suite v2.0 from the... http://t.co/DrDDPjpR | |
| sensorsonline: Host Test Suite from HART Communication Foundation: The new enhanced HART DDL/EDDL Host Test Suite v2.0 from the... http://t.co/DrDDPjpR | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Bio-Inspired Smart Camera from Brain Vision Systems: The BIPcam from Brain Vision Systems, Paris, France, is a b... http://t.co/V0FpnMJI | |
| sensorsonline: Bio-Inspired Smart Camera from Brain Vision Systems: The BIPcam from Brain Vision Systems, Paris, France, is a b... http://t.co/V0FpnMJI | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Integration of Thin-Film Thermoelectrics in New Energy Harvesting Sensor Applications: Advances in distributed s... http://t.co/Ib6URW8T | |
| sensorsonline: Integration of Thin-Film Thermoelectrics in New Energy Harvesting Sensor Applications: Advances in distributed s... http://t.co/Ib6URW8T | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: Tim Worst: http://t.co/1Dr69rS8 | |
| sensorsonline: Tim Worst: http://t.co/1Dr69rS8 | |
|
|
|
| sensorsonline: GEMAC expands its reach with innovative sensor technologies: German sensor specialist focuses on growing US dema... http://t.co/9AHfwbCJ | |
| sensorsonline: GEMAC expands its reach with innovative sensor technologies: German sensor specialist focuses on growing US dema... http://t.co/9AHfwbCJ | |
|
|
|



